Walking the Tightrope: Using Diagnostic and Environmental Perspectives in Clinical Practice

Barbara Probst, Fordham University

Abstract

The purpose of this qualitative study was to explore how clinical social workers think about and work with two distinct worldviews: the diagnostic perspective of the DSM focusing on the internal psyche, and the person-in-environment perspective focusing on the individual in context. A purposive sample of 30 clinical social workers, recruited from chapters of two professional organizations, took part in individual interviews during October-December 2010. Follow-up interviews with 10 participants in January 2011 served as a member check; an additional peer review was conducted with a second group of clinicians. Interviews were coded using hyperRESEARCH and analyzed thematically. Findings indicate that clinical social workers utilize the two perspectives interactively and holistically, with the role of the DSM moderated by severity of the disorder and practice setting. Ethical choices and dilemmas emerged as a central principle to organize participants' experience, which they viewed as a dance, balancing act, or “tightrope.”^

Subject Area

Social Work|Psychology, Clinical

Recommended Citation

Barbara Probst, "Walking the Tightrope: Using Diagnostic and Environmental Perspectives in Clinical Practice" (January 1, 2011). ETD Collection for Fordham University. Paper AAI3453853.
http://fordham.bepress.com/dissertations/AAI3453853

Share

COinS